Newcastle’s median home sale price fell by nearly half from a year earlier, yet buyers paid considerably more for each square foot of space. Redfin data for the three months ending October 2026 shows the median sale price dropped 49.3% year-over-year to $734,489, down from $1,448,600 in the same period of 2025. Over the same stretch, the median price per square foot rose 34.9%, from $435 to $586. The two measures moved in opposite directions, which suggests that the homes changing hands this fall were generally smaller or different in character from those sold a year ago, rather than that home values collapsed.
A small sample, a big swing
Newcastle has a population of 1,585 and 697 housing units, according to the U.S. Census Bureau, so a handful of transactions can move the numbers sharply. Only two homes sold in the three months ending October 2025, compared with seven in the most recent period, a 250% increase. With so few sales, one or two high-end properties can set the median. That appears to be what happened last year. This year’s broader mix of sales produced a lower median price but a higher per-square-foot figure.
The list-price data points the same way. The median list price was $692,284, compared with $1,175,000 a year earlier. This indicates that sellers were bringing more modestly priced homes to market, not that existing homes were being marked down by half.
Recent momentum has been flat. The median sale price was essentially unchanged from the three months ending September 2026, slipping 0.1% from $735,000. Home sales held steady at seven. Over a five-year span, the current median sits 1.9% below the $749,000 recorded in the three months ending October 2021.
Sales pace and supply
Homes sold somewhat faster than a year ago. The median time on market was 55 days, down 15.4% from 65 days in the three months ending October 2025, which means listings typically found buyers about 10 days sooner. That pace is still much slower than five years ago, when the median home sold in 13 days.
Inventory grew. Active listings rose 57.1% year-over-year to 11, up from 7 in both the three months ending October 2025 and the same period of 2024. New listings were unchanged from a year earlier at four, but fell from seven in the three months ending September 2026, a dip consistent with the usual autumn slowdown.
Even with more listings, supply remains limited relative to sales. With 11 active listings and seven sales, Newcastle had about 1.6 months of supply, a level typically associated with a sellers’ market. Other indicators, however, suggest buyers had some negotiating room:
- Homes sold for a median of 98.8% of their list price, slightly below asking.
- Only 14.3% of homes sold above list price, down from 50.0% a year earlier.
- Homes typically spent nearly two months on the market before going under contract.
Taken together, these figures describe a market where supply is limited but buyers were not routinely bidding above asking.
Affordability and borrowing costs
Borrowing costs rose. According to Freddie Mac data via the Federal Reserve, the 30-year fixed mortgage rate averaged 7.33% in October 2026. That compares with 6.86% in September and 6.25% in October 2025. The 15-year fixed rate averaged 6.66% in October, up from 5.49% a year earlier.
Because the median price fell so sharply, the estimated monthly principal and interest payment on a median-priced home declined despite higher rates. With 20% down at 7.33%, the payment comes to about $4,040 per month, which is $3,096 less than the $7,136 estimated a year ago. That drop largely reflects the different mix of homes sold rather than a like-for-like price cut. A buyer purchasing a home comparable to one sold last year would likely face a higher per-square-foot cost.
Affordability remains stretched. At current prices, the median home costs 6.8 times Newcastle’s median household income of $108,750, according to the U.S. Census Bureau. The estimated monthly payment equals 44.6% of median household monthly income, above the 43% threshold the National Association of Realtors uses to define affordability.
Nationally, home prices continued to rise year-over-year, according to the S&P/Case-Shiller U.S. National Home Price Index. Newcastle’s rising per-square-foot price is broadly consistent with that national trend, even though its headline median moved in the opposite direction.